Over the last few months, we have all been watching a
steady increase in the awareness of keeping our country clean. The Swachh Bharat
campaign and the subsequent photo-ops by various ministers trying to out-do
each other appeared on all our front pages, sadly in some cases, bringing the
dirt with them to pour onto the streets. I really could write volumes on what I
thought of such deliberate acts by ministers to be relevant but the truth is I
do wish to talk on an aspect of our lives that desperately needs to be given
priority as far as cleanliness is concerned.
I am referring to the state of hospitals in India. Look
beyond the plush tertiary health care centres for a moment. The vast majority
of patients (> 85 %) in this country do not have access – either financially
or just geographically - to them, after all. India, by and large, walks into
primary and secondary health care centres when they have a cold, fever, infection
or pain. And it is this section which caters to the majority that I feel has
been neglected for too long.
If you recall earlier in November 2014, a state-run
hospital in Indore called in exterminators to deal with ‘an infestation’. Only
this was no minor bug infestation as it turned out. In two days, over 4,000 rats
and mice were killed. The pest and fumigation agency noted with shock that
there were at least another 10,000 rodents in the hospital and it would take
over a month to get rid of all of them.
This was one of the biggest government run hospitals in
Madhya Pradesh and included a medical college. They looked after people of all
ages, ranging from 1 day old to a hundred years old all within that single
campus which HAS (the extermination is still underway as I type this) more
rodents than you and I will ever see in our lives.
The sad part is that this is nothing new.
Image source: here Maternity ward shifted outdoors due to construction work. How is this okay in today's India? |
Come into a packed government medical college out-patient
department on any day of the week. What do you think you will see? Hundreds and hundreds of
patients and their relatives, jostling for space to stand as they wait outside
cramped corridors.
There are people groaning in agony and sneezing and coughing
all over one another, infecting everyone around them. General wards are usually
overflowing, with patients sleeping on the floor after the beds are taken.
Rats, cats, dogs, frogs, monkeys, snakes… these are all animals I have
personally seen inside hospitals.
Cleaning the roads is fine… it is the first step towards
fulfilling the ‘prevention is better than cure’ concept. But that concept is at
least a decade away (optimistically)
from fruition. Till then, you need to be able to cure those who are ill
without allowing them to share illnesses at the very place they come to be
cured.
And it is not even a matter of mosquitoes and rodents
anymore – even invisible bacteria like Staph aureus and P. aeruginosa are
getting in on the act now. It is deeply concerning that in recent years, the
lack of adequate hygienic facilities in Indian hospitals has facilitated the
arrival of more anti-biotic resistant infections than ever before. This has resulted in
longer stays at the hospital, more expensive forms of treatment, loss of not
just work-hours but often the partial salary of the affected person and those
looking after him as well. Even within ICUs – which are traditionally the most
well-maintained and sterile areas in a hospital - the rate of nosocomial
infection is now between 11 – 25%.
It is all going downhill and it is time to refocus our
goals to arrest this apathy towards healthcare for ‘the mango people’ of the
country. The #AbMontuBolega campaign launched by Strepsils (join them here on
Facebook and Twitter) asks us to stand up and raise our voice and there is no
time like the present to demand changes for the future of the country. You cannot continue to turn a blind eye to this anymore.
You do not need to keep building new AIIMS centres all across
India. You need to invest in the existing hospitals and upgrade their
standards. Building these new hospitals
will take years… the need of the hour is NOW. Lakhs of people walk into
these centres today – you need to ensure that they walk out cured of the
disease they came in, instead of adding the infections of the people they were
standing next to in the queues.
Primary
and secondary health care centres form the largest congregation of morbid
people in India. You cannot ignore them. Take time out from inspiring
people with statues that reach for the sky and invest money in maintaining the
hundreds of hospitals that cater to 85% of India. When those who are ill get
treated and return back to work, you automatically boost your chances
of running the country more efficiently.
We need to ensure that hospitals
do not settle into mediocrity and cut corners where hygiene and sanitation are
concerned – Thousands are dying of nosocomial infections; these infections extend beyond the hospital gates to every one of us, even those who have not
visited the hospital as a result of secondary contamination and carriers. Every life affected burdens an entire family and that in
turn affects the society over a period of time. Improving health care in hospitals is as much a vital cog
as cleaning the streets in the goal for a healthy nation.
If you find yourself dissatisfied with the hygienic standards at
hospitals you or your loved ones have been to, let your voice be heard. Do
not accept it with a shrug of your shoulder. Forcing the government to invest in hospitals that exist
and in turn ensuring that these hospitals raise their standards of health care is a critical step to winning the battle against dozens of transmittable diseases which even
today literally cripple our transition from developing to a developed country.
Or if you are actually okay with sharing your hospital beds with rats and your delivery rooms with cats, frogs and snakes, well... that's up to you.
Authors note:
This is my post for Indiblogger's #AbMontuBolega 'The Power to Clean India' with Strepsils.
Wow! Some of what you share is so mind-blowing like those thousands of rodents IN hospitals: that's pretty appalling! I've heard that if you want to get sick, go to a hospital as it is often more likely that you will end up with an infection of some sort (forget the common one though think it is different from what you mention). And a maternity ward being outside the hospital while construction is going on is downright ludicrous. I can't believe what you all deal with in India though I do believe your suggestion regarding focus is spot on. All the best to you working in hospitals/health centres and those facilities as well. :) And by the way, it makes me appreciate for our health care system and our relatively clean hospital conditions, so thanks for posting Roshan! :) <3
ReplyDeleteI agree.. it is really scary... using the excuse of poverty is one thing but the level of poor hygiene is downright insane considering we are opening up a living being and operating under such conditions. Its frightening to me as a doc to see how much apathy people have towards these poor conditions...
DeleteThat is so spot on Rohan! I shudder to think what all you must see being on the 'inside'.
ReplyDeleteTrust me... there is so much any doc in India can tell you... it would make your blood curdle.
DeleteThis is so so important....This is one of the reasons I'm scared of choosing a hospital...Most are unhygienic and those that are don't have good doctors, they only speak the language of money...I was in CMC Vellore this year with my parents... I think it is the best hospital in India in terms of everything....It was surprisingly clean too and not only the private wards....Docs were great too... The condition of hospitals you mention is something that needs to be dealt with utmost priority & urgency!
ReplyDeleteI agree.. CMC maintains top notch standards.
DeleteAnd sadly, you never see any minister talk of upgrading the existing hospitals or making them better... its unbelievable that there were 14,000 rats in a single hospital and this is supposed to be one of the most famous ones in the state, apparently...
As someone who is seeing it from the inside, I am sure it must be heart breaking for you, Roshan. Let's hope something can be done with the Strepsils initiative.
ReplyDeleteI certainly wish more would be done at the ground level. The scary part is that most docs are now used to bad conditions... they accept it as normal.
DeleteWow that was alarming news for people like us who at least like to believe that hospitals are clean ! I hope this campaign becomes successful and cleanliness and hygiene become a way of life rather than duty.
ReplyDeleteThere is a big difference between the sanitary conditions in the hospitals abroad and here in general...
Delete